The declaration of war with Japan affected many people in America in a number of ways. Her parents kind of put education to the side. Mira is the other sister that refuses to give up her Indian citizenship and says that one day she will go back to her. Mukherjee spends much of the essay comparing herself to her sister, which also contains a larger comparison. Two Ways To two ways to belong in america thesis Belong In. I feel like I would have done what Bharati did by embracing the different culture.
I was prepared for and even welcomed the emotional strain that came with marrying outside my ethnic community. I do not think she left her speech community once she got married but she joined another community when she left. Critique Essay Outline First Draft Critique Essay Peer Review From Sieun Dear. There are some people who only come here to succeed but not belong in the American family because they still have love for their country. Without all this work, I would be intimidated by the article and unable to assess it.
If America wants to make new rules curtailing benefits of legal immigrants, they should apply only to immigrants who arrive after those rules are already in place. You personalized your response just enough to make a connection, but not too much that it became about you. I know that my colleagues can see me as acculturated, a centered academic at ease in my surroundings, and that I can still subjectively feel like an outsider. While Mira refrained from anything besides her original culture, Bharati embraced the different culture. Mira has become nationally recognized for her contributions in the fields of pre-school education and parent teacher relationships. My next six months of my life was worst I was depressed, sad, and stressed out. The construction of an identity in a country one has chosen involves more complex and active negotiation.
I also feel like life is going to be tougher for Mira because she did not choose to adapt to the American culture, but she chose to stay with her Indian culture. My father worked his way up to where he is and raised to me work hard for what I have. Even though they had the same idea coming to America, they both went different ways. Having predetermined goals like that can effect your speech community. The laws mistreated them, and each sister symbolizes the two type of people in America. I also find it interesting that Mira decided to hold onto her heritage and what not. The Mukherjee sisters find themselves on different sides in the current debate over the status of immigrants.
She means that she doesn't have to do all the things that would otherwise be expected of her if she would have married an Indian guy like wearing certain types of clothes or eating certain types of food. In the telegram, the Germans promised that if Mexico declared war on America, the Germans would return territories that belonged to Mexico which were Texas, New Mexico, and Arizona. The speech community is not only characterizing your speech habits. They only have a relationship over the phone. Having been awarded a scholarship from the University of Iowa, she earned her M.
I am happy and thankful to my Parents and United States for opportunity to start new life, for chance they provided to me. In the following paragraphs I will assess the strengths and weaknesses of this piece of writing along with the presentation of my arguments on the thesis. Have we the right to demand, and to expect, that we be loved? The best way to judge the right size of a portion that is correct for your body. We are no longer in the comfort of our own home or friend group and that causes us to change our dialect and speech community to communicate with all of the new people we meet in college. That sense of betrayal had its desired effect and drove me, and thousands like me, from the country. Is it focusing on strengths or weaknesses? It is very difficult if you do not talk outside of your regular speech community.
If everyone were required to learn English, including immigrants, people would get by so much easier. America gains a famous citizen. On the other hand, Bharati feels welcomed in America since it offered her so many opportunities she did not have in India. Two ways to belong in America; Reading in response to 'Two Ways to Belong in Amer. I think that it is really interested that she did not want to become assimilated with the culture of the us but she did want to marry outside of her country.
I think for a Parent main goal for my future kids prepare them when they grow up to be though and have some knowledge what to expect from life on your own and be ready for those barriers. Mira ended up marrying an Indian student and keeping her Indian citizenship and status as a legal immigrant because she wanted to stay true to her culture. In this passage we see how two of the same people can suddenly feel or experience the same thing in two different ways. They have different views on immigration. I think if you are from another country you always want to keep some memory of the place you are from.
However, I feel that, being born and raised in America, we should have higher goals than just marrying some random guy chosen by our parents. The other way is to fit in with society, and to feel as if you belong. While the Americans whites looked down upon the Indians and did not think they were real people, there was a negative relationship between the two cultures. Even though Bharati and Mira has different opinions when it comes to immigration, they both have the same sense of betrayal from the immigration policies. I need to put roots down, to vote and make the difference that I can.