Are they to be admired or pitied? Here, it indicates that the hope that may be there is fleeting and deceiving. Who would have stop them there is not law? Sometimes they are terribly sad, sometimes they are beautiful and happy. When they came to power they did all they could to create this image of a utopia propaganda, rallies, sparing no expense on the Berlin Olympics. At the beginning of the story the author paints a picture of a port town with many boats in its harbor with flags ready for celebration. The most famous was that of Kaspar Hauser, who walked into the German town of Nuremburg famous for the Nazi trials in the 1700s or 1800s.
Eventually the reason for such prosperity and contentment is revealed. Pure light grants warmth and affection, encompassing one with a sense of safety and protection. As readers who are used to reading dystopian literature can't possibly accept a utopia without some sort of catch, the just throws out the tortured child to satisfy the reader's inner curiosity. I think this is called quantum immortality. The way the people of Omelas live their lives is by thinking they are better than someone else. But how true is that statement? So who is to be pitied? It bears all their guilt. Or, they may choose to make the revelation that there should be no happiness founded on the misery of others and blindness to truth, and if there is, that happiness is hollow.
The ones still there have yet to face their inner wars. Another scenario could be that it was always meant to end when the child was gone. Once all the festivals end and the merriment is stripped away, the citizens are left with the grim notion that everything they have comes from the torment of the child in the basement. Light is the core of hope and love, the central idea for never giving up. Bells clang and people sing and dance so that the city seems alive with music. The city is beautiful, the weather and harvests are kind and abundant, and most everyone healthy 5 , yet this is just the icing on the cake.
If the child were freed, it would supposedly lead to the destruction of this great city, therefore keeping it there is for the greater good. However, all this prosperity comes with a price. Where in Omelas is Spartacus? If you remain utilitarian, then you must face that possibility or come to terms that it is wrong. The atmosphere is rich with music, festivities, and orgies. It is both good for its intriguing characterizations and sickening for its paternalistic and animalizing racism and classism. They try to distract themselves from the wrongness of their actions and hideousness of their souls. The narrator does not find the paradox in Omelas to be acceptable at all.
Dickinson experiences the benevolence within nature. Ursula Le Guin starts the short story off with a beautiful description of the city, filling your mind with happiness and joy. However, this privilege of life comes at a price. In our society, producing a child from fornication is frowned upon and discouraged, but in Omelas it is embraced fully. They see no sin in copulating randomly.
It is neither male or female. Everyone in Omelas knows about it, whether they have seen the child personally or simply know of its existence. What I mean by that is, they work 16 hours a day in poor lighting, a poorly sanitized environment, and for not much more than pocket change, so we can enjoy wearing different designer lables to different occasions and places. Omelas is a Utopian city which inhabits citizens who are pleased and content with their lives. The film Away From Her Egoyan, et al.
The point of a utopia is that everyone that lives in it has a perfect life. Only a little bit of light comes through the cracks of the floor. Children learn the terrible fact between eight and twelve, and no matter how well their parents explain and justify it in advance, the new discovery is sickening and angering 5. One more thing: Why did you feel the need to state your gender and age? They may convince themselves that what they are doing is perfectly fine, and that they will not suffer the consequences. Darkness is the epitome of fear and terror. This society is founded on the misery and degradation of one child, imprisoned in a dirty, dark cellar room furnished with a bucket and two mops, kept from human contact and sunlight.
All in all, LeGuin uses the idea of light to her advantage in the story. The author does not take a side, though. Your ideas are all very creative. It is described as happy, full of freedom and joy. To further visualize this concept, one may use this example: if an individual believes a lie with enough intensity, no matter how erroneous it is, that statement starts to sound true in his or her head.